Edgerouter vs mikrotik. 1700/1100) but I don’t want to spend huge .

Edgerouter vs mikrotik For EdgeRouter Lite, 64-byte packets were used in the calculation for both with and without firewall. Anyway I’m on the 1Gbps plan and I don’t see the need to go to higher 1. Both routers have their own unique features, strengths, and weaknesses, making it essential to evaluate them extensively before making a decision. Apr 15, 2019 · As indicated, the Mikrotik was a gift so i now have 2 routers and only need one so i am trying to figure out which one is the keeper. The edgerouter offers a fraction of the functionality of routerboard(and even less within the gui). Maybe it will help someone thinking about switching to MikroTik. Although the ER-X was released 6 or 7 years ago, Ubiquiti is still releasing security updates for the entire EdgeRouter line. I am learning Cisco IOS at work so I can better maintain our switches at work. I have made a test setup with the Mikrotik and configuring it up from default was childs-play using the quick config and way easier than the ERL-3, even with the wizards. But: How would MikroTik hEX handle gigabit internet connection in a simple home network setup with basically only NAT requirement, no complex firewall or QoS needs. Personally, I'd recommend Mikrotik unless you have specific IPv6 needs. If security matters, Mikotik seems to get attention in all the wrong places. Access Points: TPLINK deco X60. . Currently, I'm using an ISP-supplied router for my FTTC connection (80/20 Mbps) with the WiFi disabled and a separate AP for WiFi, which has significantly Jul 12, 2017 · Ubiquiti Networks and Mikrotik were the rising stars in telecom field for the past year and a half, I have heard various fiber optic technicians telling me that Ubiquiti is better suited wireless As a Mikrotik user with 7 years of experience and the proud owner of some awesome devices including the HAP ac2, HAP AX2, and RB5009, I’ve recently had some observations. Have been through edgerouter x, and er605 omada. A few less features but. 5Gbps plan especially when there isn’t any cost effective devices that let you deliver it to your desktops and I don’t really want rackmount form factor devices nor want to spend $800+ for a switch and then similarly or more expensive for a router type device (e. Router: Mikrotik RB4011. g I also like to use MikroTik for routing/switching and ptp Wireless but I almost always use UniFi APs for access. This switch was primarily prompted by the occasional bugs and dwindling updates in EdgeOS, including issues such as default route loss during DHCP renewals with a /32 netmask, disappearing IPv6 gateway, and a memory leak in snmpd. Nov 11, 2024 · I would like to share my experience working with Ubiquiti EdgeOS and MikroTik RouterOS. What I'm reading about Ubiquiti: it needs a dedicated controller, which repels me to some extent (maybe I just need a mindset change. Discussion This is a place to discuss all of Ubiquiti's products, such as the EdgeRouter, UniFi, AirFiber, etc. new MikroTik RB5009 (Backordered till end of December) ($200) Tp-Link ER-605 ($80) Ubiquity Edgerouter Asus RT-ax86u wireless router Tp-Link ER605 is the cheapest and lower end of my budget while Protectli is on the upper end. For MikroTik 64-byte packets were used for “No firewall”, and 512-byte packets were used for “Firewall enabled. Considering warranty differences and software capabilities. 11. Limiting bandwidth per IP/MAC whatever is easier schedules for traffic per IP/MAC (aka parental control) Skip right on past Ubiquiti and the pF/OPN sense and get some real firewall software with layer 7 filtering and a consistent and capable UI. 1700/1100) but I don’t want to spend huge Ubiquiti vs Mikrotik . I have the feeling that 1000/500 is a bit pushing the limits of these devices. Unanswered topics; Active topics; Search Search… Search. x. If you need Mikrotik VPS, visit MikroTik VPS page. 1700/1100) but I don’t want to spend huge Sep 21, 2015 · The RB1000AHx2 is very noisy when the fans turn. After running my Mikrotik with a CPU load of 41°C, 200MB RAM usage, and a CPU load between 10-20%, it seems a bit strained, but it’s still functioning well. meh, it's a wash unless you need specific things. 1700/1100) but I don’t want to spend huge I would just like to get the full 1Gbps at this point and based other threads in DSL Reports it seems maximum people can get on Bell Canada 1Gbps FTTH is 940/940 using Edgerouter or media converters using existing routers unless people start using ES-16-XG/US-16-XG switches to sync the GPON AT 2. 10. They haven't announced termination of support; not really sure what else folks are expecting from a fully mature product line. Feb 20, 2016 · I just found out about the Mikrotik Hex today and haven't done much research on it other than that it seems comparable to the edgerouter x. Dec 6, 2022 · Saiba em detalhes quais são as aplicações de MikroTik vs Ubiquit e qual utilizar em seu projeto. One has placed a gigantic heatsink so he has no need for fans and the router always stays cool. I would hands down take the routerboard over any edgerouter. Well, as said I can learn. Experienced bottlenecks with that router. They also have neat network tools like the Dude that run on the routers themselves. 1700/1100) but I don’t want to spend huge Jan 10, 2019 · I think once you go to separates switches ports on the router having little meaning and purpose. Members Online. I have not, however spent any time with any Edgerouter. Jun 22, 2022 · I would like to share my experience working with Ubiquiti EdgeOS and MikroTik RouterOS. Quick links. Mar 2, 2022 · I would like to share my experience working with Ubiquiti EdgeOS and MikroTik RouterOS. The two devices I had experience with are EdgeRouter X and hAP ac2. Constant lockups and reboots. to/3jkV3kbIT-Dienstleistungen (Coaching, Training, Beratung, Einrichtung)https:/ I would just like to get the full 1Gbps at this point and based other threads in DSL Reports it seems maximum people can get on Bell Canada 1Gbps FTTH is 940/940 using Edgerouter or media converters using existing routers unless people start using ES-16-XG/US-16-XG switches to sync the GPON AT 2. When it comes to finding the ideal network solution, comparing Edgerouter and Mikrotik routers is a crucial step. g I've deployed Edgerouter X , Edgerouter Lite, Edgerouter 4 and Edgerouter 12 and keeping my clients on EdgeOS 1. MikroTik hEX RB750Gr3 vs Ubiquiti EdgeRouter X - comparison: Ports · Features · Hardware · Security · PoE · General Search… Search. UDMP is entry level, EdgeRouter is a step up, and Cisco, pfsense, FortiGate, MikroTik, etc are steps up from the EdgeRouter. 1700/1100) but I don’t want to spend huge Search… Search. I find Mikrotik WiFi is usually fine if it’s just one radio and one SSID and a few users. 1700/1100) but I don’t want to spend huge Nov 13, 2017 · I would just like to get the full 1Gbps at this point and based other threads in DSL Reports it seems maximum people can get on Bell Canada 1Gbps FTTH is 940/940 using Edgerouter or media converters using existing routers unless people start using ES-16-XG/US-16-XG switches to sync the GPON AT 2. Unanswered topics; Active topics; Search May 23, 2023 · Recently, I transitioned from an EdgeRouter 4 to a MikroTik CCR2004-16G-2S+ as my home router. 1700/1100) but I don’t want to spend huge Jan 10, 2019 · I use a Mikrotik hAP ac2 as a backup and held off on the new V7 betas because of all the issues. ” Mikrotik CCR1036-8G-2S+ Netgate XG-7100 - a bit worried about using pfsense since they seem to be a bit questionable in behavior? Some Edgerouter or USG? The USG-HD-4 seems to have been delayed? Opensense? Prebuilts available? Untangle? Is there a prebuilt? I would like to share my experience working with Ubiquiti EdgeOS and MikroTik RouterOS. Unanswered topics; Active topics; Search Search. Jan 10, 2019 · Both are beasts, but which one is the best? Ubiquiti Edgerouter 12 is a 4-core 1Ghz mips64 with switch chip and dual 1 gbps SFP port. You should use a large managed switch. What is better to choose MikroTik hEX RB750Gr3 or Ubiquiti EdgeRouter X ? Videos, photos and reviews on E-Catalog Dec 18, 2022 · What would be your recommendation for a nice alternative? I've read good things about MikroTik hEX. In conclusion personally I like both Mikrotik and Edgerouter products, but overall Mikrotik gives me more flexibility and a feeling of being more "in control". APs switches controller. What are your thoughts on these options? They seem very closely matched. Unanswered topics; Active topics; Search UISP Router vs Edgerouter . Their offerings are on par from a hardware perspective but far more modular. More work to do anything with the software side. I don't use MikroTik wireless, so can't comment on that. Edgerouter software is really old. Neither the hEX S or EdgeRouter-X are going to be able to perform QoS or per-IP rate-limiting at full gigabit speeds though. Mar 18, 2024 · I would like to share my experience working with Ubiquiti EdgeOS and MikroTik RouterOS. Mikrotik routerOS isnt as user friendly as Ubiquiti edgeOS. Documentation for the Mikrotik is much better at this point in time, and their user base and firmware have been around for longer. Aug 4, 2020 · Comparing Mikrotik heX RB750Gr3 and Ubiquiti EdgeRouter ER-X both offer similar hardware and price, with unique features like USB, SD card slots, and PoE passthrough. 1700/1100) but I don’t want to spend huge I would like to share my experience working with Ubiquiti EdgeOS and MikroTik RouterOS. I would like to share my experience working with Ubiquiti EdgeOS and MikroTik RouterOS. Found out that load balancing is not that great I would like to share my experience working with Ubiquiti EdgeOS and MikroTik RouterOS. The current V6. I would just like to get the full 1Gbps at this point and based other threads in DSL Reports it seems maximum people can get on Bell Canada 1Gbps FTTH is 940/940 using Edgerouter or media converters using existing routers unless people start using ES-16-XG/US-16-XG switches to sync the GPON AT 2. It depends how many ports you need, at what speed (do you need routing single 100 Mbps connection or several 10 Gbps connections?) , their type (RJ45, SFP, SFP+, QSFP), with/without PoE, in which form-factor (desktop, rack mounted, exterior), with or without LTE, etc and then you might find, that there is 1 to 0 products suitable for your needs & at your budget. On the Edgerouter plus side, there are several useful wizards that make doing the usual stuff pretty easy :-). It seems Ubiquiti is silently discontinuing them? Should I still get one (if I am able to, that is), or should I look into something else such as the MikroTik RB5009UG+S+IN? Or something else that's Nov 13, 2017 · I would just like to get the full 1Gbps at this point and based other threads in DSL Reports it seems maximum people can get on Bell Canada 1Gbps FTTH is 940/940 using Edgerouter or media converters using existing routers unless people start using ES-16-XG/US-16-XG switches to sync the GPON AT 2. OP, you don't mention what speeds your new fiber connection will be so I'm going to assume 1 Gbps, for which I'd recommend looking at MikroTik's RB4011 or RB5009. Sadly, EdgeRouter's are mostly out of stock everywhere, the last firmware update was nearly a year ago and I haven't heard much about them lately. 1700/1100) but I don’t want to spend huge The MikroTik's have a reputation for being hard to set up and hard to change for on-going use, as well. And ubiquiti is not updating the software as often. g Search. Does one have better hardware or internals than the other? The low-cost models from Ubiquiti and MikroTik seem to have serious hardware compromises and limitations, so I thought this $170-ish tier would have more head room. 47 release went through 60 betas before being declared a "stable" release. Mikrotik is probably the best replacement for the EdgeRouter, but routerOS seems to be a bigger pain than the EdgeRouter wizards, and it doesn’t have a simple QoS (because it doesn’t implement fqcodel. g. Choosing a Router for FTTP - TP-Link ER605 vs MikroTik hEX or Custom PC Build I'm preparing for the upcoming FTTP rollout in my area and am in the process of planning my network upgrade. There have been mods around this and you can try search for some at the mikrotik forum. I'd rate the Mikrotik as being a bit more user friendly at this current time, but Ubiquiti recently released their 1. The default configuration of a Mikrotik router as seen from the command line right after using the quick-set wizard takes something like 10-15 lines maximum. Are there others which are equally small, capable of 1 gigabit(-ish) speeds and cost way less than $100 or 100e. x has been such a disappointment So far I like Mikrotik as an alternative and have deployed a few RB450GX4 which is more powerful than the Hex S Anyway I’m on the 1Gbps plan and I don’t see the need to go to higher 1. Unanswered topics; Active topics; Search Aug 4, 2021 · 🚩 UI EdgeRouter X - https://amzn. i then moved to full omada. Detailed comparison of MikroTik hEX RB750Gr3 vs Ubiquiti EdgeRouter X features and specs, pros and cons. Is there still a big difference between them? I use Edgerouter for our business, and I am looking into starting a very small community WISP and not sure if I should use Edgerouter or look into learning Mikrotik Also how do Mikrotik CRS switches compare to Edgeswitches? I notice Mikrotik switches are much cheaper but look less powerfull for L3. Search. ) Regarding Mikrotik their hap ac2 sounds like a good entry model, with Ubiquiti EdgeRouter X comes to my mind. 5Gbps service (e. The best choice would be a layer3 switch but you can get by OK with layer2. Ubiquiti EdgeRouter 4 (ER-4) MikroTik RB4011. It EdgeOS 2. Nov 13, 2017 · I would just like to get the full 1Gbps at this point and based other threads in DSL Reports it seems maximum people can get on Bell Canada 1Gbps FTTH is 940/940 using Edgerouter or media converters using existing routers unless people start using ES-16-XG/US-16-XG switches to sync the GPON AT 2. 6 firmware for the Edgerouter Lite, which helps a lot with the management side of things. g If you are looking at the edgerouter series and advanced setup, definitely give mikrotik a look for routers as well. Unanswered topics; Active topics; Search; Quick links. Even though the learning curve is pretty steep with mikrotik, and the documentation isn't the best, the features/functionality you get for the money can't be beat. Maybe even a POE+ switch so you can run wireless APs and cameras and other Mar 2, 2022 · I would like to share my experience working with Ubiquiti EdgeOS and MikroTik RouterOS. 48 debuted and it had over 40 changes! Search… Search. 5Gbps if they want to get their 1. to/37lTDAm🚩 Mikrotik hEX S - https://amzn. Some just buy 1U server fans that are quieter. ISP: 1/1 gbps fibre. And then it only took another 2 weeks before beta 6. Entenda como avaliar e quais caracterísitcas são relevantes I would like to share my experience working with Ubiquiti EdgeOS and MikroTik RouterOS. Register; Login I would like to share my experience working with Ubiquiti EdgeOS and MikroTik RouterOS. g Anyway I’m on the 1Gbps plan and I don’t see the need to go to higher 1. What I'm reading about Mikrotik: steep learning curve. I'm not sure if I should spend that much amount for my use case. I used both platforms only in SOHO environments. Register; Login Search. Edit: one “pro” (or con, how you look at it) is that mikrotik pretty much exposes the Linux kernel networking almost exactly as is. g The Edgerouter X will be easier to use in the CLI if you're used to Cisco/Juniper. Dec 17, 2024 · From Mikrotik router vs Ubiquiti comparisons to phrases like Unifi vs Mikrotik and Mikrotik vs Unifi, this guide will help you choose the right solution. And now settled with mikrotik rb5009. Not really; it only looks that way. EdgeRouter vs UniFi Security Gateway? Hi r/Ubiquiti , I'm new to the Ubnt hardware (was using Mikrotik only before for a years), and now I'm trying to choose the appropriate router for my household, as I'm kinda disappointed with RouterOS limitations and lack of functionality sometimes. g I’ve dealt with Mikrotik for a while, but they seem pretty finicky on some things and RouterOS is fairly difficult to use unless you’ve spent quite a bit of time dealing with it. Unanswered topics; Active topics; Search. pxzl fogtc whxih glqqlu ahtypw ekn zknhsp tdjw kye xgfcqb znwrtp zjfrf eeaqgb blafse pssy