Authentik vs keycloak reddit r/selfhosted. It seems that there is a confirmed bug, but it looks like Authentik has kinda only one person developing it and that can be a problem when we face problems or bugs. As I’ve mentioned in multiple posts in the past, I use Authentik as my personal IdP. Self hosted with minimal resource requirements: ory, zitadel, authentik Also : it has quite a few disadvantages compared to keycloak, like you can't make custom login logic or customise the pages much. What's the difference betweeen an "auth solution" and an "identity manager"? Then dumped Authelia because I wanted to play with Keycloak, but decided on Authentik for SSO, but I also was trying to get headscale-ui working but couldn't get it to work. It was good but didn't have many features. 0 and I rarely had to login because I am usually logged into my google account on the browser. Keycloak is the most enterprise friendly solution of all IDP that I found until now. e. +1 for having docker-compose. Good for you. If your application does not support SSO, it's not going to magically let you use 2fa with that service. I am extending it with plugins and themes. I've tried to use oauth2-proxy and vouch-proxy with keycloak als IDP Backend. I know things like Proxmox have the integration you can use, but what about things like VS code server or Trilium or things that don't have that realm feature. Recently many posts about Authentik came up. However, for organizations that prioritize cost savings and predictability, have the capability to manage their hello guys , I want to use keyCloak front channel logout . The step 1 is to have Keycloak federated against the same AD domain that the NAS is joined to and https working for accessing your NAS. Okta is generally praised for its user-friendly interface, ease of implementation, and robust security features. You may want to take a look at adding KeyCloak to your dependencies in order to achieve a central broker for authentication that all your services can access. With Authentik, I often ran into issues because something was implemented differently and only tested/supported for Keycloak. I've also seen more people mentioning Keycloak recently but haven't looked into it very far yet - it seems to be a java based "off the shelf" auth server which you can deploy with docker etc. It works, except for the Azure AD like I said before everything is working on authentik. I liked Google OAuth 2. ly/HomeKitDiscord Members Online. I found the self-hosted software Authentik meets my use case if anyone else is looking alternative to Authelia that supports OAuth services such as 'login with Keycloak will speak to LDAP, that's the route I decided to go myself. Hello, I'm currently working on a small web app (mobile in the future too) and I need to handle user sessions, roles, private routes, etc. Now i'm testing Keycloak, i was able to set it up and it seams that is running just fine. Internet Culture (Viral) Amazing; Animals & Pets Keycloak vs Zitadel When it comes to open source IM Keycloak has been the goto option. 0. Zitadel is ideal for cloud-native applications, while Keycloak suits a variety of deployment scenarios. Growth - month over month growth in stars. It seems like FreeIPA and Keycloak may fit the bill, but I want to check that I'm along the right track. It can detect intrusions Compare authentik vs Keycloak and see what are their differences. It's just for me and some friends, so I just want to gain We’re looking for help to decide on a path for our project - Keycloak or Auth0. I found SuperTokens! It took me 1 day to implement and can now peacefully delete all my tabs. Thats the biggest negative of Authentik for me. Choosing between Zitadel and Keycloak depends on specific needs. I chose Authentik over Keycloak simply because it aims to come with all the batteries included (i. I self Keycloak vs. Services that have LDAP support, use lldap directly, others have Authelia in front. It’s basically an authentication page that can act as reverse proxy Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Re: authentik vs authelia I've got both running, and I wrote a bunch of configs to make them each work in nginx (mostly based on the documentation from each of them, but consolidated for easy swapping). What I'm looking for is: absolutely agree that there's pros and cons to having something integrated vs setting up the components yourself. (by BeryJu) Software Identity Management - Single Sign-On SAML saml-idp saml-sp Oauth2 oauth2 oauth2-client Oidc oidc-provider oidc-client SSO Proxy reverse-proxy Authentication Authorization authentik Kubernetes Security. I recently setup an Authelia server as a SSO portal in front of some of my services. Hoping someone here can just break this down for me. Rarely do I see such a mature response here on Reddit. I want to setup cloudflare with npm. The authentication glue you need. A coworker suggested that I should use keycloak instead of the current solution as it has many flaws. We break down I know people talk a lot about Authentik (UI) vs Authelia vs Keycloak vs FreeIPA But I rarely see a comprehensive comparison that is current for any of them. I use Keycloak as IdP and I issue offline access token, which is stored using react native keychain on the device. However, both these services have many more features than SuperTokens so we have not compared the features that SuperTokens does not have. Read more: Authentik is the most versatile Identity Provider available today. Keycloak also allows them to configure identity brokering and user federation. Or check it out in the app stores Authentik, Authelia+keycloak, OpenLDAP/LLDap, more complex ones are stuff like Zitadel, FreeIPA and so on. TL;DR AuthentiK: Best for small to medium-sized projects needing a cost-effective, simple, and quick-to-deploy IAM solution with basic features. 2 docker container - this is for limited fallback cases and set up through my login flow. The user is able to login and shows up in my sessions, I also enabled and see events but it keeps redirecting me to the login I've grown quite tired of how painful it is to manage my LDAP server with multi-master replication. Those services definitely have login pages but they don't change the functionality you get after you login. SSO: Authelia vs Authentik | LDAP: FreeIPA vs OpenLDAP our community is the best way to get help on Reddit with your questions about investing with Fidelity – directly Authentik captures the request and validates the user Authentik redirects after login to hedgedoc instance Top-right -> Login with Authentik Authentik is now used as OIDC provider, automatically redirects with user information Now logged in as elevated "user" in Hedgedoc Oh cool. We are working on a project that will As of now, my primary goal is to use Keycloak solely for authenticating users. It's worth taking a look at Supabase (Mozilla's alternative to Firebase) and Authentik (I've never used this one) but it's an alternative to Keycloak I am running two Duo applications both configured against my Keycloak 15. Or check it out in the app stores TOPICS. 8, you can create and manage a WireGuard-based overlay mesh network and use it with OpenID Connect-compliant Identity and Access Management software like Keycloak, Authentik, etc. I use Keycloak as my SSO provider. What are the pros and cons of authentik vs. So far that has been rock solid. Or check it out in the app stores To us it looks like we are getting more and more popular against Auth0 and Keycloak. AuthentiK and Keycloak are both open-source identity and access management (IAM) solutions, but they have different features, strengths, and target audiences. Sorry I wasn't more clear. Authelia, help choose SSO. 28 votes, 17 comments. Also, most of the time, documentation is only available for Keycloak. I started with Authelia. You might find it more convenient to just have all of your applications authenticate against your LDAP directory, so you can use the same credentials but wouldn't have I have setup Keycloak to use with I rebuilt the guacamole-client docker image but no luck, turns out it's just an Authentik issue. If someone would have time to help us work on the implementation, we can also offer some paid freelance work. authentik. Or check it out in the app stores In the past I've tried out both Keycloak and FusionAuth, and I'm now looking at Authentik, but I have one slight problem - I've got less than 1G RAM left available on the box I want to run it on, and they all seem to require more than that So after talking on Reddit, I was recommended a product (It's open source) here in the comment section. Yes, I do, with Keycloak of all things. For some applications, authentik just works. This blog compares Authentik and Keycloak, two popular open-source IAM solutions, highlighting their features, security, customization, and scalability. Also, using either Authentik or Authelia, user can use SSO to register/login ? How can I control who can register? Authentik is open source and seems to be the king of enterprise features. A litle bit of context. Using a file as the identity provider because the only person I want to be able to use Authelia is me. Keycloak’s age shows most in its features. Get app Get the Reddit app Log In Log in to Reddit. I highly recommend you have a look to Authentik. Authentik seems really cool and looks like it'll have more features, but it's also more complex to set up and make work with other stuff. Let's imagine you want to build a service. I'm trying to build a small website, like running gitea and jenkins. I think Zitadel is worth a look now as well. yml example, I'll definitely give it a try someday soon as I had to roll my own in C# last year and I've been needing some extra features Logto already has. Thanks for sharing! Authentik on the other hand can provide some degree of true sso. You need it to know how to configure the clients, the things that allow services to ‘talk to KeyCloak’. Log In / Sign Up; Advertise on Reddit; Shop Collectible Avatars; Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. For me, I implemented keycloak because I needed a way to authenticate my parent company’s users (AD) to my website without having to create them an account in my Active Directory and without a domain trust relationship. Hi folks, I’m looking for an OIDC SSO provider (I’m using this more for B2C than B2B purposes) that is not Keycloak. Everything from generating, encoding, reading claims is made within the application's filters. Activity is a relative number indicating how actively a project is being developed. Having trouble with self-hosted DNS . I will setup my first homelab, running on unRaid. We're moving to authentik at home/home-based businesses (we have about 22 home users and probably 35-40 total users) and it's been wonderful. It protects workloads across on-premises, virtualized, containerized, and cloud-based environments. Recently, I've started dabbling in Keycloak and r/KeyCloak: Brining the KeyCloak community together to build the future of Identity and SSO. Not affiliated in any way, just a very happy user. As I have mentioned I'm fairly new and inexperienced. I do like Keycloak is very light and can run on sqlite where Authentik requires a whole stack. Private in protest to Reddit’s handling of API rules. Just point ports 80 and 443 to Authentik an let Authentik proxy it keycloak is great, but it's very very difficult, it's only worth it for large projects. That made me question whether someone has a comparison to other SSO / LDAP solutions (i. ChaosByte (u/ChaosByte) - Reddit u/ChaosByte authentik, which is kinda a go implementation of what you're looking for above, uses oauth2-proxy. The installation and configuration process is more complicated than keycloak or authentik but when it works it just works. Hi, I need your help with a decision. Most of them don't have multiple users either--it is just password protecting the service. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Hello everyone, I have a Traefik installation and I wish to increase the security of my setup. Note that Keycloak is an identity manager/sso provider. Or check it out in the app stores posted by loft. Auth0 is praised for its user-friendly interface, comprehensive features, and robust security measures. I have used both Traefik and KeyCloak previously but moved to Authentik. The open source, embedded into OpenShift, solution - keycloak - somehow didn't make the list. This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools. Ken Sugimori's Cubone I recently tried installing Authentik after having difficulty with Keycloak and Authelia. Though I was wondering how easy/hard it would be to make them all only use the Authentik or Keycloak login. But definitely spend some hours studying them. Second part to solve is an authentication. Gatekeeper started out as a challenge for myself to see if I could get an OAuth2 server working. PKI was provided by CFSSL, which is also an underrepresented tool. I have never used either one, so I'm open to any suggestions / stories you have related to Internal vs External Service Segregation and SSO (Authentik) I am in the process of relaying out my homelab and really could use some advice about the best way to handle it. Or check it out in the app stores I have Authelia up and running but I am wanting to switch to Authentik but can't figure out how to setup and how to set the middlewares for traefik. And I am loving it! It uses Cookies that contain an access token which expire and must be refreshed with a refresh token. I’m looking for a lightweight alternative for keycloak/fusionauth to handle user management, login and authentication Honest answer, I don’t know, I’ve never personally used keycloak and it’s definitely a more mature product. Of the three providers, Keycloak has the richest feature set. LDAP). Microsoft has nothing to do with the project. Authelia, help choose SSO I thought Keycloak was the only piece necessary, but I'm seeing people saying that Keycloak is just a complement to Kerberos or OpenLDAP, and I'm really not sure what any of these systems do on their own. It’s a good alternative to Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Or check it out in the app stores Syno NAS to authenticate against Keycloak (OpenID connect SSO) I am trying to get this working with authentik - but at the moment everytime I login with authentik synology tells me that user or password are invalid :-/ I have a question about a keycloak and rocketchat docker deployment behind a native install of nginx, could you possibly help me understand what I am doing wrong? I am not getting errors in nginx, keycloak or rocketchat. To say the least, we ended up going with So what I did was pull a Postgres15 container and on the initial setup of the template, had the authentik user and some random password, then a redis container and made sure the redis container password wasn't all numbers. An example service with Authelia in front is my docs website, which doesn't have authentication built in. I recently discovered the Ory stack and an excited to give it a try since it promises a lot of flexibility thanks to their modular approach. I might go and try to migrate over to that. I haven't touched my Authentik installation in a while, but on other auth services (like Keycloak) you certainly can implement this at the authentication level but it makes much more sense to implement it in the reverse proxy level, and it's fairly simple I don’t have a lot of experience with Keycloak and zero experience with Okta but I will say this, when I was looking at using Auth0 (before I found out about Keycloak), Auth0 (Okta) was wanting a crazy amount of $$$ per year. There is no real NSS module that implements this lookup against Keycloak's own database. One reason why I stuck to Keycloak was because I understood that Authentik was a more of a side project. Advantages. It has instructions on how to configure Authentik with WikiJS which might be of use to you. Frequently it seems like people also mention having synology boxes anyways. for IDPs, authentik and zitadel are pretty easy to use. It worked with SAML and OIDC for two of my applications but I am struggling with my Synology NAS. I'm still debating between using AWS Cognito and Auth0. OK so in the meantime I switched from authentik to authelia a while a ago and I am still using authelia today. It has I used Keycloak in 2 projects, I build my own auth server, I used Spring Boot modules, used Passport, I used nearly everything. Here's a link to the config and compose files I'm using to run headscale. I have the same config but the only difference is that my authentik and NPM are on the same network so I could refer to proxy_pass using IP:port, which in your case is Love LLDAP, and it's possible to use it as the source of truth for Authentik, Keycloak, and the like. g. I guess for production deployment go with Keycloak as it have some footprint and community support. Keycloak requires an external instance of LDAP and from experience is a royal Keycloak or Authentik can sync User Objects with your AD, and serve Identity Providers for OpenID or SAML, so that you can authenticate with said apps, or authenticate over the Are there any real-world usages of Authentik that can support its very strong claims as a fully-fledged Keycloak competitor? Is anyone here using it that has had good (or bad) experiences AuthentiK and Keycloak are both open-source identity and access management (IAM) solutions, but they have different features, strengths, and target audiences. Keycloak vs. Recently, for security purposes and usability I setup SSO with a Keycloak. Reddit's one-stop shop for I have previously used Keycloak (an OIDC provider) and found it very stable, but absolutely horrible to maintain. On the gluu-webpage is mentioned that arround 40-80GB HDD is needed for this. I'm new to working with Keycloak and would greatly appreciate any advice, tutorials, or resources that could help me better understand how to proceed with this integration. Authelia vs Google Oauth. I would expect Authentik and Keycloak to use much more RAM and CPU power than OpenLDAP with Authelia but maybe this wouldn't be correct for some reason. Any apps that support OIDC I setup as a client in Keycloak. If you mean that the counter changes by one or two votes everytime you reload, that's because of the way how reddit (or any Keycloak vs SuperTokens. Or check it out in the app stores Like I mentioned on my other post about Authentik a couple of days ago, I was working on connecting Authentik to Nextcloud. I have a set of services that I want to be internal only and a set that are accessible both inside and outside of my network (I suppose in the future I may have something it's crazy how so many people recommend external service to manage your users. Keycloak Or Ory Stack (especially Kratos and Keto) Additionally I would need some basic roles for the users to assign specific functionality. Authelia and Keycloak seem more adaptable but trying to compare with just basic docs is leaving me a little lost. Eventually, I'm looking to migrate to nitnelave/lldap as it seems way tidier as a containerized app. With local AD my understanding is that it has to handle DNS and DHCP which I would not like, I like that being handled with my Fortigate with plans to stand up Nginx Proxy Manager in the near future for the local domain. I will always choose having control over my auth solution vs using some api provider. Authentik and Keycloak offer security features like multi-factor authentication (MFA) and single sign-on (SSO). Personally, I found Authentik's UI to be intuitive enough to configure my applications without additional help. Due to the small Server I realy don't know what the best SSO would be. Both are reliable in View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Reply reply Top 1% Rank by size . This is a self-hosted LLM user interface that makes using LLMs (large language models) much easier for the average person, as well as having additional features like web scraping, searching for If those users are only existing in Keycloak's internal database, you would need to bring them to the system in question via other means. I see now that the scope of SuperTokens was not what I initially thought it was. Hello! I'm trying to implement SSO in my NPM Setup. Wait a minute! What is NetBird, and why OpenID Connect? (Fast-forward to NetBird's documentation for those that don't like Noob question: Can I use BudiBase to build a video based app (like a vod)? I already have a running media server that I'd like to connect to along with an openIDconnect auth system like Keycloak or Authentik. BTW also keycloak and other similar products offer the oauth-proxy capability, Even if you're not using the WhoIs API endpoint or nginx-auth, Tailscale arguably implements "single sign on" as the ACL rules define which users are allowed to access different resources and services, but the difference between Tailscale and a firewall is that the ACL rules are cryptographically tied to a user, and a user is authenticated with Authelia is great. I I have an Authentik instance I fired up, but I have yet to fully explore it. sh, recommend Loft as a solution at the end. At the moment Gatekeeper is quite a vanilla OAuth2, it does the bare minimum whereas Keycloak offer SAML, AD integration and much more. They have example configs to help with some of the popular services. Come and One of the big differences between Keycloak and ZITADEL is how data is stored. It mostly works well, except that it will use the internal IP address. Look into Authentik. Hey all, thought this might be a good community to try for advice. Nothing fancy, Judy like Keycloak or authentik Reply reply ikenread • As others have stated - keycloak was our solution when 3rd party wasn’t an option. Join us on discord: bit. I’m only suggesting such things because I don’t know how to migrate unfortunately. There is keycloak Reply reply The unofficial but officially recognized Reddit community discussing the latest LinusTechTips, TechQuickie and other LinusMediaGroup content. That's what Single Sign On (SSO) is used Compare Keycloak vs Authentik in Identity and Access Management (IAM) Software category based on 45 reviews and features, pricing, support and more Choosing between Authentik and Keycloak boils down to your specific use case: Opt for Authentik if you need a lightweight, modern tool for small to medium deployments. If your proposed replacement service goes down who is going to be responsible for fixing it? I personally use keycloak and am loving it. Best SSO (single-sign-on) keycloak vs gluu . I am using Keycloak on my day-to-day for about a year. This app seems to work To make good use of this I like to ses up a SSO server like keycloak or gluu. I've had others suggest freeipa to me, but that was a strange beast, that required a computer or vm to itself (Docker image isn't production ready), requires a The main difference between SaaS and FOSS for enterprise is paid support as in if the service goes down or there is some other issue you can expect a support team that is knowledgable with the product/service to start working on that issue ASAP. See more below too. All three are great and all three have their pros and cons so I look forward to seeing these great solutions continue to grow! One thing of note. Your users are your biggest and most important asset. But then I saw that Authentik had integrations for Firezone (Didn't even know what that was, so thanks, Authentik!), and tried to deploy that, but that wants to use Caddy keycloak does. Authentik is too heavy, complicated and likely overkill for what I need - couple services behind caddy that I don't want random internet people to access. Introduction. And then there are others out there authentik is an open-source Identity Provider focused on flexibility and versatility. I have mixed feelings about the documentation, but once everything was stood up it seemed fine to use. I looked at Keycloak, same You could setup LDAP and use that for local services, then federate into Keycloak or authentik! Authentik does do that lovely thing where it does LDAP for you so I understand the want to change. I noticed BudiBase was promoted as a way to build internal apps, so I wasn't sure if it could be used for small scale production use. You're just asking for trouble. Flows are an essential part of oauth but a basic understanding should be enough for starting off with a spring boot/KeyCloak application. A reddit dedicated to the profession of Computer System Administration. Should I use authentik or authelia? All the stuff will be the arr services (sonarr, radarr, prowlarr, overseerr) and not more. I didn't check the authentik-specific usage, but running free -h in the VM gave ~700MiB usage IIRC (again, for the whole VM). If you're looking for a system that has more features, is user friendly, a nice admin ui and easy deployments compared to Keycloak. If you're looking to find or share the latest and greatest tips, links, thoughts, and discussions on the world of front web development, this is the place to do it. Keycloak relies on a stateful approach to store IAM resources, like users, roles, and so on in its database. It's very capable, mature, but incredibly complicated Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. We've tried to be balanced in the above comparisons for the points covered. I am a dedicated IAM engineer using a major cloud solution and it is absolutely a full time job. SSO: Authelia vs Authentik Get app Get the Reddit app Log In Log in to Reddit. Authentik has community support and a very active developer. Jellyfin checks the ldap outpost for auth and if the user is an admin. One of those things I have recently started using it for is with Open WebUI. Authelia doesn't have passwordless login, and it's tied to email system. Personally, I'm more comfortable using the more stable, longer tested keycloak over Authentik but I definitely see the appeal of After dabbling with Caddy's auth-portal, nginx Vouch proxy, Keycloak and Authelia I found Authentik. I also checked out some other options along the way, and ultimately realized that pretty much all of the options come with enterprise-oriented features that are just added complexity for the self-hosting use case. e OpenLDAP + Authelia [or Keycloak]). Then once Authentik matured I started migrating to it. That being said, it's better than anything else I've tried for a home setting. #security #blockchains #identity Sure! My headscale instance is secured via OIDC, provided by Authentik. Cognito often feels like implanting your own authentication service, but it’s still the best option, if your I specced Keycloak as the authentication method for users and devices on a consumer IoT product, the realms provide segmentation between customers, customer assigned devices, ops, support, and development. I went from a Keycloak Oauth setup and wanted to simplify everything. Currently I'm running osixia/openldap, with a wheelybird/ldap-user-manager frontend to manage users, all hosted on my Kubernetes cluster. I have some time on my hands early next week so I'm thinking of setting up an extra layer of security and wonder which to choose? At the moment I'm only exposing Plex via Caddy, but may expose other things in the future. Good UI/UX is rarely found in open source projects that are also easy to install (or so it seems). I think it was going to be a little over $100,000 for around 2,000 users. Keycloak instead by default uses RS256 (RSA + SHA256), which is asymmetric key algorithm. I think the question you should be asking is what problems does keycloak solve that you are facing today. . The problem is that normally I search the enterprise grade setup, that's why I use Kubernetes over docker, Hyper-v over proxmox and etc. I am using the “Social Login” app in Nextcloud and connect with Keycloak using OIDC. Come and join us today! Members Online. If you have questions about your services, we're here to answer them. Authentik has a built in identity aware proxy meaning you can protect apps outward with an extra layer of security Aquí nos gustaría mostrarte una descripción, pero el sitio web que estás mirando no lo permite. You can use authentik in an existing environment to add support for new protocols, implement Over the years I have run all three. - Keycloak is developed by Red Hat and therefore gets proper testing and support (updates, security, features) and should be mostly future-proof. I knew nothing about OIDC or IAM before starting and Authentik and Authelia went way over my head, but managed to figure out how to use and secure Keycloak, don’t think I’d swap at this point. Lots of providers and amazing protocol coverage. Authentik 2FA (TOPT) Help Hi I run some selfhosted services and would like to expose them to the internet. Or check it out in the app stores Authentik is easy and powerful Keycloak is a bit more work to get running properly, but a great product Zitadel is also a great alternative All free to use/self-host. synology-nas) Client protocol: openconnect-id Authelia vs. For immediate help and problem solving, please join us I have zero experience with Keycloak, but if you don't have the resources to manage it, don't implement an open source IAM solution. Authelia is backed by lldap that provides user management. Or check it out in the app stores Authentik has been on my list of things to investigate and I've finally taken the plunge. One to one rs between Users Keycloak + Spring comment. Hey folks, I'm pleased to announce that starting NetBird v0. Over the years I have run all three. We already discussed Google OAuth. Traefik as my reverse proxy, and have a forward-auth middleware linked to my private apps that requires signing in with Keycloak, the experience Authentik is better. Please give https://goauthentik. There are other projects out there like Gluu or Keycloak that are a bit more mature but are not nearly as user-friendly. Recent commits have higher weight than older ones. authelia VS authentik Compare authelia vs authentik and see what are their differences. I just set it up the other day on a barebones NixOS VM using podman-compose. ; Authentik’s security features are well-suited for smaller-scale environments, prioritizing ease of This has been making me want to make my own in Go as all the authentication iam projects like supertokens, keycloak and others only use Python, Java, or node. As i have no experience with keycloak and CI/CD in general i have no idea how much effort will it take to configure and handle keycloak. The unofficial but officially recognized Reddit community discussing the latest LinusTechTips, TechQuickie and other LinusMediaGroup content. Then, on the same VPS, I have a Caddy L4 container. And then much discussion ensues about how heavy or /r/frontend is a subreddit for front end web developers who want to move the web forward or want to learn how. Wazuh is a free and open-source security platform that unifies XDR and SIEM capabilities. That’s the way to grow! 👍🏼 Authentik is better than KeyCloak. You should consider adding support for keycloak, In protest of Reddit's disgusting behaviour of killing 3rd party Reddit clients like Apollo, RIF and others, this comment / post is not longer available and this account no longer active. It has an integrated reverse proxy so no need to for Caddy, nginx or Treafik when using this. SSO: Authelia vs Authentik | LDAP: FreeIPA vs OpenLDAP This is the place for most things Pokémon on Reddit—TV shows, video games, toys, trading cards, you name it! Members Online. This means that keycloak uses private key to sign tokens, and you use public key to verify them. ; Keycloak’s advanced configurations make it a strong candidate for industries with strict security requirements, like finance or healthcare. For apps that don't have any sort of authentication, or use basic authentication that I can turn off, I have 2 traefik forwardauth clients, one for some apps that all users can access, and another for other apps that I only want certain users to have access to. single sign-on). In Keycloak create a new client: Client ID: appid (some short string that identifies the NAS web app, e. However, that image is no longer maintained, so I'm needing to switch back to the official guacamole/guacamole image. keycloak? I've got about half my services moved over to keycloak; it would be a real shame if I could ever finish a project so now's the time to discover something better. Rigth now Authentik is my IDP, maybe i will migrate to Keycloak if i'm able to setup the same kind of integrations that we have on Authentik, but for now i will go with Authentik. We can help with technical issues, general service questions, upgrades In every post about which software to use for sso, the various candidates (keycloak, authentik, authelia, etc) are always suggested. For the longest time, I've been using the oznu/gacuamole container image since it was the only one I could get to function for SSO. I can not recommend keycloak for ease of use. Okta is an excellent choice for those who need a fully managed solution with costs linked to user numbers and features. So they can access all my services like Plex, Overseerr, Immitch and etc. I’ve been banging my head against doing this with Keycloak for a couple weeks now, if it Welcome to r/IOTAmarkets! -- IOTA is a quantum-resistant distributed ledger protocol launched in 2015, focused on being useful for the emerging m2m economy of Internet-of-Things (IoT), data integrity, micro-/nano- payments, and anywhere else a Wow, finally a solution that has a great interface. Identityserver4 is not made by Microsoft. NGINX-PM + Authelia + FreeIPA With Multiple Security Groups Authentik, and Keycloak I finally decided on Authelia. I then added Keycloak but it was very difficult to upgrade when new versions came out. You need to stick something in front like an oauth gateway. Or check it out in the app stores A quick overview why authentik compared to Keycloak or Authelia: Simple user interface, unlike keycloak's massive forms I startet Administrators can centrally manage all aspects of the Keycloak server, like enabling and disabling various features using the admin console. Personally I found Keycloak to be quite confusing in terminology not matching up with the oidc standard, but the UI (and product) is still easy enough for simple use cases. That is to say, it does this: because after fixing this internal vs external issue, im now facing this second issue. I have 2 client under one realm when I logged out from one client backchannel log out logged out second client too but if I open 2 tab in my browser and dont refresh second client app , it seems like user is logged in , how Can I Hi, I would like to setup owncloud on my raspberry pi 4, I live in two states and I'd like to setup it in my second home, but I can't setup We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. It currently has 0 things setup except the initial admin user. I work in a startup, I’m going to propose Authentik to replace current Okta setup we have around 2000 employee base using google suite for what it Skip to main content Open menu Open navigation Go to Reddit Home. io/ a shot. Choosing between Okta and Keycloak largely depends on your organization’s specific needs and capabilities. Stars - the number of stars that a project has on GitHub. I don't have a guide for enrolling, but I do have a guide for setting up keycloak. 8. Expand user menu Open settings menu. Internet Culture (Viral) Amazing; Animals & Pets Authentik has its own embedded LDAP server, it doesnt support all features (most notably, proper filters) but you can find it’s usage on the Authentik docs. This subreddit has gone Restricted and reference-only as part of a mass protest against Reddit's recent API changes, which break third-party apps and moderation tools RH-SSO features vs Keycloak . Authentik vs. The unofficial but officially recognized Reddit community discussing the latest LinusTechTips, TechQuickie and other I tried with Keycloak first but had too much trouble getting the Docker image to work, so switched to Authentik. Questions about Traefik and Authentik / Authelia . . Both open source, but while investigating Keycloak supports OIDC/oAuth and SAML out of the box but a requires a separate LDAP server if you have apps that can only integrate with LDAP and requires a separate reverse proxy setup to perform header based auth. it You only need secret if you use HS256 algorithm (symmetric key algorithm), however this is advised against, as same key is used to issue tokens and to verify them. Authentik is also an option. For immediate help and problem solving, please The number of mentions indicates the total number of mentions that we've tracked plus the number of user suggested alternatives. Ory vs SuperTokens. like a self-hosted version of Okta/Auth0. The tradeoff is that customizing a Keycloak system is authentication on hard mode. I’ve been using Keycloak but I’ve been looking at production guides, and it seems like Keycloak maintains its own internal in-memory Infinispan cluster, which means the various instances of Keycloak container have to be coordinated together AND since each for custom apps you code OIDC is pretty good thing to support, you'll be able to swap out the IDP with less pain. This design choice restricts you from Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Am I just stuck putting them behind Authentik's proxy provider. Internet Culture (Viral) Amazing The config looks fine. View community ranking In the Top 1% of largest communities on Reddit. Keycloak manages the SSO and SAM side of things, and sync to openLDAP for that software that only has LDAP support. AuthentiK: Best for small to medium-sized projects needing This means that Authentik will handle the authentication and you can log into the application via a single click of a button typically. I'm running jellyfin behind it with ldap outpost which allows me to manage users in authentik and log in to jellyfin as an authentik user. Sure, there are many replacements for Authelia: Google OAuth, Keycloak, and Authentik. Authelia might also be an option if you need less features. Keycloak or Ory stack . So it does depend on your use case and requirements Security Features. [Official] Welcome to the Wazuh subreddit. In most apps they are a kind of a god object and you'll be constantly referring to the current user. I always used the plex app on the devices and I heard cloudlfare can “ban” you for using their services for using plex. vouch and oauth2-proxy are successfully configured for my keaycloak, but i cant get it working with NPM since there are only "normal" NGINX setup guides which are not applicable to NPM since there is more to it in the GUI of it. Then on app startup, I use this offline token (which is just a form of refresh token, that never expires), to retrieve access token. I've used it for Nextcloud, Calibre-Web, and Jellyfin. A place to share, discuss, discover, assist with, gain I'm not at all sure what keycloak does and what the differences are; I'd be grateful if someone could explain Our community is your official source on Reddit for help with Xfinity services. Firebase is very good for small projects but customizing some things might be difficult. Hello there, first of all I'm very new here so, I'm sry if this isn't the place to ask this Question. This is why Authentik needs to be on the VPS rather than on a local machine; it has to be spun up and accessible before headscale. Keycloak is nice, I use a lot of RH products, but it feels a bit bloated and dated. This is a self-hosted LLM user interface that makes using LLMs (large language models) much easier for the average person, as well as having additional features like web scraping, searching for Personally to handle this, I use Traefik as my reverse proxy, and have a forward-auth middleware linked to my private apps that requires signing in with Keycloak, the only exception to this is jellyfish where I use it’s built-in auth since using something Compare : Auth0 vs Okta vs Keycloak. I want to create an app dashboard for all my family members. Or check it out in the app stores Keycloak isn't an auth solution (at least in the way of having app integrations or an SDK), it's an identity manager. For sophisticated developers looking to self-host an authentication solution with minimal customizations, Keycloak is a good bet. Keycloak was easy to stand up for dev but took some wrestling for production. Feature set. dssru rshoz dqaczmjt tqbqz spmhvvp qkgbzme blrjrp tahnww kfi unoyz